The World’s Most Peaceful Land Dispute

September 15, 2016

hans-islandHans Island is nothing but a barren piece of rock with an area of only a one-half square mile. It sits in the north Arctic in the Kennedy Channel between the extreme northern borders of Canada on one side and and the Danish territory of Greenland on the other.

This island is uninhabited except for the birds that visit it, but it has become an spot for a dispute over who claims it as their own. Canada says its theirs while Denmark insists it belongs to them. The result has been a fight over a piece of land that can probably be considered the most peaceful land dispute in the world.

There’s really not much to fight over with Hans Island. It has no resources and isn’t in an important geopolitical location, but the countries of Denmark and Canada have been “fighting” over it since the 1930s. Because countries can claim land that is within twelve miles of their shores as their own due to international law, Denmark and Canada have each said that the tiny piece of land is theirs.

The beginning of the dispute can be traced to a 1933 decision by the League of Nations Permanent Court of International Justice. The court decided that the territory belonged to Denmark. But as the League of Nations was later replaced by the United Nations, the decision by the court became largely ignored.

Hans Island sat without a conflict until 1984 when the Minister of Greenland Affairs from Denmark decided to place a Danish flag on the land accompanied by a bottle of brandy and a message that said, “Welcome to the Danish island.” Since that time, both countries have waged a “war” that is being fought with their own flags, messages, and whiskey.

When the military of either country visits the island they dismantle the other country’s flag, but they also leave alcoholic gifts. The Danes now leave a bottle of schnapps and another “Welcome to the Danish Island” sign, while the Canadians leave Canadian Club whiskey and a “Welcome to Canada” sign.

Of course there has been political wrangling on both sides that amounted to mostly tough talking statements, but the dispute continues. An end to the disagreement may be in the works however. In 2008, a group of international scientists put up a weather station on the rock outcropping, and a proposal was in the made to share the territory between the two nations. The proposal, however, was ultimately abandoned.

While both countries couldn’t come up with an agreement, they may be pressed into action by another source–Russia. Russia has been increasing its activity in the north Arctic. The increase in Russian ships and military aircraft near the two countries’ borders might push them into a resolution as their focus moves from Hans Island to the northern portions of the Arctic and Russia’s push for more oil and fishing rights.

The fate of Hans Island remains to be seen. Until then, both sides will be enjoying a good laugh and a hearty drink.

Sources: World Atlas, CBC, Business Insider, The Star, Wikipedia

Top Photo Credit: Toubletap/Wikimedia

About the author 

Daniel Ganninger - The writer, editor, and chief lackey of Knowledge Stew, the author of the Knowledge Stew line of great trivia books, and editor of Fact World and the Knowledge Stew sister site on Medium. I hope you find things here to annoy those around you with your new found knowledge.

Follow the Stew

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}